Saturday, 3 March 2012

twilight adventures: part one
























At the end of last year, I was given a significant amount of book vouchers. For someone who often prefers to hang out with books rather than people, having this much to spend on books was understandably a really exciting prospect. So much knowledge - om nom nom!

So, people were surprised to hear what I purchased with a decent chunk of that book money, to say the least.

I bought the entire Twilight series.

Because of this, I've had comments from people questioning my sanity, religious convictions and even my sexuality (possibly understandable). People can't understand it. If they aren't mocking me when I bring it up, people seem to want to know why I would do this to myself, from what seems to be genuine concern. Hilarious.

Well, while it is an empirical truth that 'haters gon' hate' I would like to explain myself because what I am actually trying to do is more than just indulging my inner 14 year old female self.

For better or worse, Twilight is a cultural phenomenon. I have a lot of friends (sure, they're all female) in their mid-twenties who love the book series. They couldn't put it down. One friend finished all four books in five days. I almost considered challenging that bench mark. The movies followed fast and for a period of time there was a lot of talk about 'Team Edward' and 'Team Jacob', closely followed by remarks from incredulous young men along the lines of "Isn't it just a story about one girl's choice between necrophilia and bestiality?" As it turns out, kind of.

It seems that some Christian friends of mine cast a disapproving eye on it all, simply because it contains characters that are vampires and werewolves, and fear for my inner spiritual life while I read it - what if I get caught up in it all and develop an unhealthy fascination for the occult? Isn't it true that what goes in comes out? If you put evil stuff in you're gonna turn evil! I’m going to intentionally dismiss that thinking because, quite frankly, it's superstitious.

My thinking is that if I want to understand the culture that I live in, and to be able to communicate the true story of love well, I have to be familiar with stories that shape thinking. And unfortunately, the Twilight series is one of them. It has helped to shape the way that millions understand true love, and to a lesser extent myths about dark creatures. So it wasn’t enough to do the research. In order to get my head around the way in which the saga has become such a phenomenon I had to get into the books. Because I would rather stick pins in my eyes than watch the movies again.

James Davison Hunter describes four main ways in which Christians can respond to culture:

Defensive Against - set ourselves up as an opposing force, kind of like a morality police where the other team gets demonized. Culture outside of Christendom is just bad, we are the goodies and so it is time to be grateful for a life watching Sunday School Musical and enduring endless movie nights crying along to A Walk To Remember.

Relevance To - in order to communicate well to those outside of the church, we pretty much have to look just like them. Lifestyle choices are secondary to being able to relate. Heaven forbid that people would think that Christians are different! No way babe, it's all good if we hook up at this party as long as we talk about Jesus afterwards.

Purity From - think Amish. The world is beyond redemption so the best thing to do is seperate ourselves from it completely so that we don't get defiled. Your school friends are dirty. Stay at home and watch Shine TV, there's a good girl.

Faithful Presence Within - and here we reach the jackpot. Really, there is no 'us and them'. There is a good and loving God desperate to be in relationship with all of humanity and we happen to be the current lucky recipients of that. The problem is, not everyone has seen what we've been shown and so we need to be able to take stories, ideas and symbols and reorient them around the person of Christ.

This is why I'm reading Twilight. I have a hunch that some of the ideas about love and relationship and spirituality that are presented in the book are distortions of the truth, but I can't really comment unless I know what I'm talking about.

So join me as I venture into what is proving to be some of the worst literature I've ever read. Hopefully we'll see what the real danger is. Pray that I won't fall for Edward. It's hard. He sparkles.

5 comments:

  1. love it Sam - went through the same thing when Harry Potter came on the scene! All that magic and spells and magical creatures and witched and wizards... oh hang on an i taling about 'Potter' or 'Lord of the Rings' or even, dare i compare, C.S Lewis and the Lion the witch (the what?) and the wardrobe. Actually Harry Potter started my oldest on his love for reading and the use of his talented imagination.. I loved the books personally (offically vetting them of cause) . So go for it sam and keep us posted... personally i belong to team Bruce - sexier that those two put together any night of the week! But then it is an exclusive club.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I actually think it's quite cool that you're reading the Twilight series... I really loved it when I was reading it... Partly because it is just mindless trash... I look at it like eating a big bag of chips.

    But actually, I think the reason so many girls love it is because when you boil it down, it's about a plain-jane girl who some how ends up having two extraordinary guys fall in love with her (though neither of the guys are actually that appealing, they both have their flaws in different ways)... It's about a girl who gets pursued... and that's what every (most) girl wants. They want to feel like they're valuable princesses rather than plain-jane's they probably consider themselves (or worse depending on their self esteem)... They want to take that thought of "no one will want me" and get proven wrong... The fact that one is a vampire & one is a werewolf is almost irrelevant...
    If you read a lot of trashy teen fiction (like I have) you will see that this exact story line (or other variations) are all exactly the same. And it's not just in books, but it's in every girly movie or tv show... It's gotten to the point where it's hard to tell if that's what girls have told the media they want, or if that's what media has told girls what they want... It's probably both.

    Anyway, here is a video that I hope will help get you through the terribly written story: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2L253VLwH3w&ob=av3e

    ReplyDelete
  3. That is a great comment Rach, I'll keep all that in mind! And that video is fantastic. Hahahahahaha.

    ReplyDelete
  4. That video is funny! I read the books over Christmas, and look forward to hearing your thoughts. Incidentally I'm now studying post-grad stuff about JK Rowling, CS Lewis and JRR Tolkien... :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Mean! Why am I not surprised? Haha. Would be good to hear what you learn!

    ReplyDelete